future OpenWrt security support
Jo-Philipp Wich
jo at wwsnet.net
Sat Oct 3 12:59:32 PDT 2026
Hi Hauke,
I agree with the overall assessment, and would like to add a few
observations about the reports themselves.
I have the feeling that a lot of the recent reports are primarily
motivated by recognition or CVE attribution rather than by genuinely
improving the project. In one instance a reporter publicly bragged about
having found a root RCE, which turned out to be a weakness in
luci-app-bmxd, a package that is rarely, if ever, installed. A lot of
the reports target the restricted ubus ACL handling, which is not
employed by default, and many of the presented vulnerabilities require
various non-default packages and/or non-default settings to become
exploitable at all. The result is that genuinely exploitable-by-default
issues get swamped by "trivial" advisories.
For LuCI I have seen basically identical advisories published by
different persons at different times. From that I conclude that everyone
with access to the current LLMs can find the same issues without any
deeper expertise, and that any AI-found vulnerability can be
rediscovered by any other interested party with roughly the same effort.
For this class of issues the responsible disclosure process is
essentially worthless: it needlessly ties up resources and forces us
into the GHSA / CVE request / attribution dance that nobody has time for.
I would suggest we do not take security reports for non-default
configurations too seriously. We should focus on fixing issues in the
default configuration and issues that are likely to occur, e.g. in
popular packages or commonly used settings. Concretely:
- Treat such reports as ordinary bug reports and simply fix them, rather
than going through the advisory process.
- Encourage the creation of pull requests fixing the issues instead of
advisories.
- Disable the GitHub security advisory reporting on our repositories, it
attracts drive-by bot traffic.
On shortening the support period: I understand this given the situation,
and it is likely the only way forward, we cannot force volunteer work.
On the other hand, the OpenWrt system sees a lot of churn, frequently
explicitly dropping or accidentally losing hardware support, leaving
users in the rain with regard to security fixes.
~ Jo
More information about the openwrt-adm
mailing list