[VOTE] Switch 'master' to 'main' branch for repositories

Felix Fietkau nbd at nbd.name
Mon Feb 27 23:22:42 PST 2023


On 27.02.23 23:36, Rafał Miłecki wrote:
> On 27.02.2023 23:20, Jonathan lancett wrote:
>> Hi people should cast there vote yes or no and then get on with there day If I could vote I would vote yes, but there is no point bickering about it.
> 
> I disagree. For half (or whatever) of the voting time it wasn't clear
> what exactly are we voting about. I mean: real motive. I find that
> critical as that may affect further project direction.
> 
> For the other half of the day I just followed discussion and I still
> have some comments to share. I'll just start with somethig simple for
> now.
> 
> If we've voting for "main" branch name due to some policy, I'd like to
> know specfic rules. I'm afraid we may be opening a can of worms.
> Who's going to decide what words should be banned and on what terms?
> 
> I was already told that some consider "blacklist" and "fat" inproper.
> What about word "fast"? I'd say "slow" may be considered negative by
> some people.
> 
> Should we limit banned words to branches only? Or code too? Or patch
> author names? What to do with contributors with names including "good",
> "white", "queen" or "king"?

The proposal I made is specific and very limited in scope. I don't have 
any further agenda with it.

Other people may have different ideas of what kind of changes they would 
like to see next, but that's out of scope and needs separate proposals 
anyway, which you're free to argue against when they show up.

All this excessive speculation and the weird hyperbolical comparisons is 
just off-topic rambling and doesn't help in any way.

Can we please stay on topic and have a simple vote?

- Felix



More information about the openwrt-adm mailing list